The Variations Between a Gradual Cooker and Dutch Oven (and When to Use Every)


We might earn a fee from hyperlinks on this web page.


There was a time once I would confuse the phrases “Dutch oven” and “gradual cooker.” I couldn’t let you know why, however it was in all probability as a result of I had by no means actually operated both of them earlier than and these imprecise, old-timey titles fused collectively in my thoughts. (I envisioned a cauldron over a fireplace.) Effectively, let the report present that they’re not the identical. Not solely are they fully dissimilar in appearances, however they focus on considerably totally different cooking duties. H

Each cookers are recognized for his or her gradual and regular cooking properties, and resulting from their deep form, the Dutch oven and gradual cooker are each good candidates for high-moisture meals. The largest distinction is that one is a correct digital equipment, and one is, effectively, a pot. 

The gradual cooker

A slow cooker on a countertop.


Credit score: Allie Chanthorn Reinmann

What’s it?

The gradual cooker is a cooking equipment that features a light-weight (often aluminum) housing with an electrical heating aspect on the backside. There’s all the time a heavy ceramic vessel that sits snugly into the housing and that is the place the meals cooks. Oh, and there’s a lid. The lid suits loosely and that looks as if a mistake at first, however it’s not purported to be tight—steam is meant to softly escape throughout cooking. 

On the entrance of each gradual cooker is a management panel. This could be a easy rotating dial, or it could possibly be an entire digital show with buttons and a timer. The settings are often excessive, low, maintain heat, and the period of time it’s cooking for. Here is the one I’ve, and it really works effectively for me.

When to make use of your gradual cooker

The electrical heating aspect within the housing gently heats the ceramic inside vessel to a spread simply round boiling. Relying on the mannequin, low temperature could be round 200°F and it could solely go as excessive as 300°F. With temperatures this low and mild, you may see why it’s referred to as a gradual cooker. Most issues that go in will take over an hour to cook dinner. That makes this equipment nice for hands-off cooking the place you need flavors to deepen and meld, and hard meats that might profit from the tenderization of low, gradual warmth. 

The place the gradual cooker actually shines is with set-it-and-forget-it cooking and holding meals heat for a protracted time frame. Because it’s not cooked on the range and your entire heating mechanism is enclosed, the gradual cooker is protected to depart on the counter unattended. (So long as you belief your cats to depart it alone. It’s a raffle for me.) The gradual cooker could be a large helper when it is advisable liberate the range and oven, like for Thanksgiving. I feel the “maintain heat” perform is the largest boon for social gathering internet hosting. I’ll maintain an enormous tank of Swedish meatballs heat in a big gradual cooker, and a small batch of mulled glögg steaming in one other.

Arrange the gradual cooker for:

You wouldn’t use the gradual cooker for something that must be completed rapidly, or something that requires excessive warmth. For instance, you may’t sear one thing within the gradual cooker. It’s a greater device for boiling, steaming, or holding moist meals and drinks heat. 

The Dutch oven

A blue Dutch oven on a stove.


Credit score: Allie Chanthorn Reinmann

What’s it?

A Dutch oven will not be an equipment in any respect. I’m prepared to guess that the phrase “oven” within the title is what throws off most individuals. Within the easiest phrases, it’s a heavy-duty forged iron pot with a lid. There are not any shifting elements, no plugs, and no instruction guide. The fanciest factor about it’s the enamel glaze that may are available a rainbow of colours and makes the inside considerably non-stick. I’ve been fairly obsessive about mine this winter. My Dutch oven was a present and it has no model title (most of the inexpensive ones are simply nearly as good as the flowery ones), but when I had been to purchase one other one it might in all probability be a Lodge.

When to make use of it

The Dutch oven excels at holding onto warmth for lengthy intervals of time and distributing it evenly due to its dense partitions. They’re additionally oven-safe as much as 500°F (and possibly larger, relying on the model). That makes this pot nice for something that must be cooked for a protracted time frame, any meals that transfer from the range prime to the oven, or issues that profit from roasting in an enclosed area within the oven. 

The Dutch oven is a superb vessel for frying because the thick steel retains warmth higher than a skinny pot. You received’t should maintain messing with the flame to take care of a 350°F temperature. My favourite issues to throw in Ol’ Dutchie are bread for the elevated oven spring (the ultimate rise a loaf of bread does within the oven) and soup or stew. In case you’re in want of a recipe, my crispy hen and rice recipe actually reveals off what the Dutch oven is able to. 

Pull out the Dutch oven for: 

You wouldn’t use the Dutch oven for something that you just wish to cook dinner rapidly as a result of it takes so lengthy for the steel to return as much as temperature. Frying eggs, fast stir-fried noodle dishes, and whipping up grilled cheese sandwiches are nonetheless greatest completed in a basic frying pan.

How to decide on between the 2

The subsequent time you are making pulled pork, stew, or white bean chili, you could possibly attain for both cooking device. When deciding between the 2 I often ask myself a couple of questions: Do I wish to do some work or virtually no work, are there powerful cuts of meat I would prefer to tenderize, and the way a lot time do I’ve till I wish to eat? If I’ve a couple of hours or powerful bits of beef to cook dinner, I am going to in all probability dump the elements within the gradual cooker. If I wish to eat throughout the hour and/or the meal has seared and simmered parts, I am going to doubtless flip to my Dutch oven.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back To Top